A co-worker of my wife asked me to put together a list of the three most compelling reasons to switch to a Macintosh. Here’s the email I sent in reply:
Hi –
My wife asked me to send you a brief email listing my top 3 reasons to use a Mac.
Turns out that thinking this through has been a very interesting exercise.
The answers in my mind are pretty simple, but they have very subtle implications.
1. Apple designs computers for the end-user.
Windows seems to be designed for Microsoft’s primary customer, the large corporate sys-admin. Windows has superb tools to let a single administrator easily control thousands of workstations. But this power comes at the price of relatively easily exploitable security holes. It also means that since Microsoft focuses on the sys-admin tools, the GUI and user-space gets less polish. The opposite holds true for the Mac. Given that Lehigh is not really using Active-Domain to manage computers to the degree that they could be managed, the end-user focus of the Mac seems to be better suited to student and faculty users. If Lehigh was Ford or Wachovia (randomly chosen large corporations) it would be the other way around.
2. Apple is built on Mach and Darwin (and descended from BSD).
Building on a mature multi-user operating system brings obvious advantages to security. But there are more important implications. Building on Unix means that the Mac is as facile on networked systems as Linux or other Unix based systems. Microsoft’s TCP/IP networking has been vastly improved over the years, but it’s not at the same level as a Unix descended system. Daemons stay where they’re supposed to stay. User space is discrete and one user doesn’t tromp on another user. (Which if you’ve ever had to use the computer terminals in the Technology Classrooms, you’d recognize why this is so important to me.) Mac’s can use Fink to access RPM’s and apt-get repositories to use pretty much anything put together for Unix and/or Linux. (LaTex? Oh yes!)
3. OSX uses open-format data when possible.
This is the primary reason I switched earlier this year. Having had a hard drive crash and struggling to get my data out of Outlook and onto a spare linux machine I has sitting around I realize what a pain vendor-lock has become. The Mac uses mbox for email, uses simple xml and/or html and pdf for documents, vCard and iCal for address and calendar. All of which can be easily backed up and imported into another system. Having managed to move 20 years worth of files from one computer to another, being able to do that easily and get access to the files once moved is critical to me. The Mac does in natively. Windows does okay – sort of – as long as you use Windows to read the data. I won’t even go into the goodness of spotlight and metadata searching…
There you are. I’d be glad to expound on any of the points. Oddly enough my favorite thing about Mac’s didn’t even make it on the list. Once I convince a person to switch, they quit constantly calling me for support. They just start using their computer. 🙂